Cheap flights from Toronto Island to New York

Compare Toronto Island to New York flight deals

Find the cheapest month or even day of the year to fly to New York

Book the best New York fare with no extra fees

Flight deals from Toronto Island to New York

Looking for a cheap last-minute deal or the best round-trip flight from Toronto Island to New York? Find the lowest prices on one-way and round-trip tickets right here.

Don’t miss a great deal

Stay one step ahead. Find the best value travel with the latest deals, tips and news.

You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy for more info.

Find the cheapest month to fly from Toronto Island to New York

We’re always keeping an eye on fares, so you can find the best one in seconds. It looks like Toronto Island to New York flights are currently cheapest in June.

Direct flights from Toronto Island to New York

Alternative Toronto Island to New York routes

Looking for the cheapest, fastest or easiest route from Toronto Island to New York? You could fly into the following airports instead.

Toronto to New York: Flight information

The things to know before you go.
Cheapest flight foundC$245
Cheapest month to flyMay
Average flight time1 hr, 30 mins
Most popular airlinePorter Airlines (Canada) Ltd
Average flights per week123

Finding cheap flights from Toronto Island to New York: Frequently asked questions

There are 6 airports in New York: New York LaGuardia, New York Newark, New York John F. Kennedy, Westchester County, Islip, and Stewart International.
The best price we found for a round-trip flight from Toronto Island to New York is C$245. This is an estimate based on information collected from different airlines and travel providers over the last 4 days and is subject to change and availability.
1 hour and 30 minutes is the average flight time from Toronto Island to New York.
Porter Airlines (Canada) Ltd and Porter Airlines Inc fly direct from Toronto Island to New York.
There are 123 flights per week flying from Toronto Island to New York, as of May 2024.
The cheapest month to fly from Toronto Island to New York is usually May.
If you're flying from Toronto Island Airport, the cheapest airport near New York is New York Newark – which is 14.1 km away from the center of New York. We've found flights to this airport from C$245.
After crunching the numbers on our flight calendar, we found that it's currently cheapest to fly from Toronto Island Airport to New York on Wednesday, May 29, 2024.
Yes – the average flight time is 1 hour and 30 minutes.
We show every price from over 1,200 airlines and travel agents, comparing them all so you don’t have to. If you know you want to fly to New York but you’re not ready to book, set up a Price Alert. We’ll track prices for you, and let you know when they rise or fall.
We crunched all the numbers in our flight calendar, and it looks like the cheapest time to book a flight to New York is around 40 days in advance, so don’t leave your flight to the last minute.
In May, the average temperature is usually around 14°C. July is typically the warmest month in New York, when it usually averages around 27°C. You can expect the least rain in February. The coldest month is January, with temperatures averaging -4°C. The rainiest month is August.
Currently, Porter Airlines (Canada) Ltd offers the cheapest flight tickets to New York.

Flying out of Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport

Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport (YTZ), also known as Toronto Island Airport, is quite unique. To get to this island airport, you'll have to either take a short ferry ride or walk the pedestrian tunnel. You'll want to arrive at least an hour before your flight, with your airline ticket and valid passport. You won't need to obtain a visa to visit New York City.

Unfortunately, you cannot fly direct from YTZ to New York City. However, via Porter Airlines you can fly direct to Newark, New Jersey, which is about 24km from Manhattan. If you want to fly to a New York airport, you will have at least one layover, likely in Boston or Montreal.

New York Airport Options

Since Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR) in Newark, New Jersey is the only airport to which you can fly direct from YTZ, it likely makes the most sense to fly there. A taxi ride from EWR to Manhattan will cost between $65 and $95, depending on your exact destination. You can also take the AirTrain for around $18, or rent a car if you're willing to brave the New York traffic yourself.

Depending on where you will be staying in New York, LaGuardia Airport (LGA) or John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) might be the better choice, despite the required layover. LGA is best if you will be staying in Long Island or on the east side of Manhattan and JFK is best if you will be staying in borough neighbourhoods like Park Slope or Brooklyn Heights.

What to Expect in New York

There is no time difference between Toronto and New York City, and little climate difference, though Toronto can experience colder winters and more snowfall. However, as one of the USA's most costly cities, there is a significant difference in average prices. New York prices are much higher than Toronto prices, made even worse when the Canadian dollar is low. Be sure to save as much as possible on transportation by using Skyscanner's Price Alert tool.

As one of America's coolest cities, there is no shortage of awesome attractions in New York City. You'll find incredible shopping and heavenly food choices down every street. Don't miss visiting the Statue of Liberty, the Empire State Building, Rockefeller Center, or the Metropolitan Museum of Art.


More flight options

Prices shown on this page are estimated lowest prices only. Found in the last 45 days.