Fire Island Hotels
Find the best Fire Island hotel for your dates, by price or preference
Compare hotel deals across hundreds of providers, all in one place
Look out for Fire Island hotels with free cancellation or excellent ratings
Trusted Fire Island hotel providers
See all hotels in Fire Island
Hotels in Fire Island rated best by other travelers
Rated by travelers as the best in the city, these stays all get 5 stars for cleanliness, customer service and location.
Luxury stay or budget getaway?
Whether you're after 5-star comfort or ease on your wallet, we do the searching so you can sleep easy during your stay in Fire Island.
Find a Fire Island hotel in the heart of the action
Beat the lines at the top Fire Island attractions by staying close to them.
Fast facts
Sleep easy, armed with the stuff that's good to know before you go.| Highest-rated hotel | Grove Hotel – 4.8 |
|---|
Your guide to finding the best hotels in Fire Island, New York
Make the most of your time in Fire Island by finding a hotel that matches your style. We’ve collected some of the city’s best hotels, from luxurious to modest.
Best time to visit Fire Island
The best time of year to visit Fire Island depends on what you’re looking for (or hoping to avoid) during your trip in terms of things like weather and price. Low and high season in Fire Island
Busiest month(s): Fire Island experiences its peak tourist season in August, resulting in an average nightly rate of $376. For those booking a vacation during this period, it's recommended to budget for higher costs compared to less busy seasons, which offer average nightly rates as low as $289.
Quietest month(s): The cheapest time of year to visit is July, when the average rate per night is $289, which will save you more money than peak season.
August is the most expensive month to stay in Fire Island, so plan accordingly. When prices peak, you should be ready to spend an average of $376 per night on a hotel stay. Prices are usually highest on Tuesday. No matter the time of year, Wednesday is generally the cheapest day to book.
Where to stay in Fire Island, New York
With Skyscanner, it's easy to find the best Fire Island hotels — from 5-star to the most booked — at a price you want.
