Your guide to finding the best hotels in Shelter Island, New York
To make the most of your time in Shelter Island, book a hotel that’s right for you. We’ve picked some of the city’s hottest hotels, from luxury to budget-friendly.
Best time to visit Shelter Island
When you're planning your vacation to Shelter Island, consider what you hope to do (or avoid) during your stay in terms of things like weather and price.
Where to stay in Shelter Island, New York
The most in-demand hotels are popular for a reason, and Skyscanner helps you score the right one at the best rate.
Popular hotels in Shelter Island
Here are some other great hotels in Shelter Island:
The 2.5-star Dering Harbor Inn provides a relaxing stay in the middle of Shelter Island, where you can enjoy its pool, gym, restaurant, and spa.
If you're looking for comfort and affordability, try the Shelter Island House. Its 3.5-star rating ensures exceptional value, and you can enjoy a range of amenities like the free Wi-Fi, fitness center, restaurant, and room service.
Rated as a 3-star hotel, The Pridwin Hotel and Cottages offers a wide range of amenities, such as a free Wi-Fi, Complimentary breakfast, fitness center and pet-friendly policy.
With a modern and comfortable design, the Sunset Beach is a 3-star hotel that provides free Wi-Fi, parking, 24-hour front desk, and air conditioning.
Things to do in Shelter Island
At the heart of the city, you can find well-known attractions and things to do like the Sylvester Manor Educational Farm. If you're a food lover, you'll find a smorgasbord of great places to eat, like Vine Street Cafe, Stars Cafe, Commander Cody's, The Islander, and The Pridwin Restaurant.
